Sia Reclaims Her Rejected Songs On The Excellent ‘This Is Acting’

by Madeline Raynor

What happens when a songwriter pens a tune for a client, but it gets rejected? Does it get wadded up and tossed in the trash? Or does the writer sing it herself? The latter approach is Sia’s solution on her new album, This Is Acting: every song but one was originally written for another artist.

Sia’s side-business of writing hits for pop stars like Rihanna and Beyoncé is well known. After a successful alternative pop career, Sia took a break from being a singer to write hits (or, more accurately, co-write them) for others. Her last album, 1000 Forms of Fear, served as her comeback, full of energetic tracks that sounded like a strange but wonderful combination of electro-pop and Top 40.

Singing songs she originally wrote for others is not new for Sia. She wrote “Titanium” for David Guetta, which he released with her demo vocals—without her permission. She’s also covered “Diamonds” (written for Rihanna) live. Now she’s reclaiming the very songs that were rejected by her clients, and in doing so, showing us that rejected songs don’t have to be failures. 

Sia’s radical concept is executed beautifully. This fantastic record opens with the empowering “Bird Set Free,” an energetic song about survival. In the pre-chorus, Sia harmonizes with herself on the line “I don’t wanna die,” turning it into a defiant prayer. When the chorus comes, it’s a surge of pulsating energy that leaves no doubt that the narrator will overcome.

“One Million Bullets,” the only song on the album that Sia originally wrote for herself, starts out like a mellifluous lullaby, showcasing the lower part of her vocal range before transitioning to a chorus belted with almost tangible feeling. Throughout the song, the ends of words are drawn out in vocal ripples and echoes, stunning examples of the unique vocal embellishments that Sia is known for. 

Another highlight is the hypnotically catchy track “House on Fire,” which showcases Sia’s slurred vocal style. “Space Between” stands out as a slow ballad with bare, gorgeous vocals that recall Sia’s early hit “Breathe Me.” Unfortunately, however, the concept isn’t failsafe: “Move Your Body” and “Sweet Design” stick out as songs that don’t work as well for Sia’s vocal style.

With This Is Acting, Sia also shines a light on the process of writing songs for pop stars. As an innovative experiment, This Is Acting is a success. As an album, it is fantastic. It feels like part of a natural progression for Sia, and an excellent way for her career as an artist and as a songwriter to exist in harmony.

Sia’s This Is Acting  is out now on RCA Records! Click here to download it on iTunes.

Image Via RCA

More from BUST

Notes On Why Playing Music As A Woman Is Still Fucked Up: BUST True Story

Guaranteed To Give You Life: This Fleetmac Wood Dance Mix

3 Must-Read Music Memoirs

You may also like

Get the print magazine.

The best of BUST in your inbox!

Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

About Us

Founded in 1993, BUST is the inclusive feminist lifestyle trailblazer offering a unique mix of humor, female-focused entertainment, uncensored personal stories, and candid reporting that tells the truth about women’s lives.

©2023 Street Media LLC.  All Right Reserved.