Rachel Maddow and Conservatives Clash on MSNBC

by Intern Kelsie

File this under Reasons Why Rachel Maddow is the Dreamiest. On yesterday’s Meet the Press, MSNBC’s First Lady of political commentary sat down with Hilary Rosen, Alex Castellanos, and Cathy McMorris Rodgers to discuss the political climate and policy formation of the current administration while examining Romney’s Republican campaign. This video is maybe the clearest example I’ve seen of the total breakdown of communication between the parties in this election. When exactly did Democrats and Republicans start speaking different languages?

Rosen and Maddow outline the policies that keep women subjugated, economically and personally, touching on the Fair Pay Act of 2011, which would work to undo some of the subjugation, and on the more than a thousand bills introduced on the state level that seek to curtail women’s access to reproductive rights. McMorris Rodgers counters, saying that Republicans won the women’s vote in 2010 and that the War on Women is a myth created by the Democratic party to “distract from the real issues.” 

This is not a myth. This is real life

Maddow begins by saying women make less than men, an economic reality that Mr. Castellanos then explains by saying “There are a lot of reasons for that.” 

His reasons? Men simply work more than women! Men enter into professions like engineering, science, and math! Maddow’s response: “Listen, this is not a math is hard conversation!” Castellanos embodies the patriarchy, interrupting Maddow and congratulating her on her “passion” but not her intelligence. It’s frustrating to even watch.

But Maddow holds her own and calls Castellanos on all his crap: “That’s really condescending. This is a stylistic issue. My passion on this issue is actually me making a factual argument.” By refusing to quietly accept Castellanos’ misogynistic comments, Maddow is exposing the way the Republican rhetoric works. Already this debate is the subject of intense scrutiny from many media outlets, framed either as Maddow schooling Castellanos or Castellanos having to endure the crazy rantings of left-wing, lesbian Maddow. In an interesting take, Jason Easley at Politicus USA claims:


The video below captures the heart of the clash, but for the full debate, click through to Huffington Post.

[video:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6NYHWp31u40 425×344]

Image source RachelMaddow.com

You may also like

Get the print magazine.

The best of BUST in your inbox!

Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

About Us

Founded in 1993, BUST is the inclusive feminist lifestyle trailblazer offering a unique mix of humor, female-focused entertainment, uncensored personal stories, and candid reporting that tells the truth about women’s lives.

©2023 Street Media LLC.  All Right Reserved.