Now, I haven’t been keeping up with all the drama—I refuse to watch another 40-minute Tati video—so I don’t know exactly what’s going on with Tati and Jeffree Star and James Charles and all of that.
However, I do know that many of Shane Dawson’s old videos have resurfaced (again) and many are calling for the YouTube veteran’s end on the platform.
Dawson has been making videos on the platform since 2008, according to the New York Times. In many videos from Dawson’s earlier years on YouTube, he can be seen perpetuating racist stereotypes in blackface, using the n-word and making masturbation jokes about then 11-year-old Willow Smith, which Jaden and Jada Pinkett Smith have spoken out about.
Jada and Jaden Smith are not accepting Shane Dawson’s apology ❌ pic.twitter.com/somhgoZown— Tea Dribble (@TeaDribble) June 27, 2020
Dawson previously addressed these misdeeds in the past but made another video on June 26 apologizing for them again and vowing to do better in the future. However, many online are saying that his apology was full of excuses and pointed out that he was an adult when he made the videos and should have known better.
Shane Dawson’s racist and problematic behaviour is on another level, sorry but that “apology” wasn’t enough... in fact it wasn’t an apology at all it was just full of the same old excuses...why are black people always your f*cking punching bags?!— ????? ????? ? (@mimithenerd_) June 27, 2020
Others have called the apology insincere and pointed out that despite his previous apology for similar jokes, he continued to sell and promote “Shanaynay” merchandise — a "ghetto" character—and made money off of the racist videos on his channel up until recently.
Why Shane Dawson didn’t take accountability, hasn’t changed, and why I’m not accepting his apology: a thread pic.twitter.com/fz50otH5xU— Tenpura #BLMs (@Discardedsushi) June 27, 2020
Since then, YouTube has announced that it will temporarily suspend monetization of Shane’s three channels (with a total of roughly 34.4 million subscribers), according to TubeFilter. However, it is not clear how long this suspension will last and what lasting consequences Dawson will face on the platform.
The platform did something similar when Logan Paul uploaded his infamous Japanese suicide forest video in which viewers saw Paul and his posse filming with and making jokes about a man they found who had recently committed suicide. Paul’s ad revenue was temporarily suspended but quickly returned and his channel hardly took a hit from the incident, according to The Verge.
Dawson has been facing consequences in other aspects of his career as well. According to Insider, Target has announced that it will no longer sell Dawson's two books: I Hate Myselfie and It Gets Worse. Makeup brand Morphe removed Dawson's Conspiracy makeup line from its website, which he created with beauty YouTuber Jeffree Star, who is also facing backlash. According to Insider, Morphe has not publicly announced why the products were removed, but they no longer show up on searches of the website.
This all seems to be an attempt to clean up the platform. Earlier this week, YouTube removed channels of people like former KKK leader David Duke and white supremacist Richard Spencer for violating the website’s laws on hate speech, according to The Guardian.
Whether or not this is a sign of significant progress for the website, it definitely sends a message to creators and viewers alike about what racism can get you on YouTube.
Header Image: Screenshot from Dawson's newest video.
More from BUST
Evi Arthur is a graduate of Roosevelt University with a bachelor’s degree in journalism and media studies and a minor in women’s and gender studies. The former editor-in-chief of her university paper, Evi has previously interned at Chicago Agent Magazine and St. Louis Magazine. A St. Louis native (and lover of St. Louis-style pizza), she plans to eventually return to school and earn a Master's degree in investigative reporting. You can follow her at @EviArthur on Instagram and Twitter.